March 11, 2009
Posted: 1920 GMT

KABUL, Afghanistan - I knew something was wrong the minute I took a look at the police sniffer-dogs tasked with protecting a key checkpoint just outside the walls of the presidential palace. They looked tired, they weren't interested in the cars, they had to be coaxed into sniffing around and they had sores on their hind legs. Great, I thought, that's all that's coming between me and a catastrophic explosion in Kabul: Work weary dogs and their underpaid masters.

Can you really blame the dogs or the cops though? Kabul is clogged with traffic and people and at the best of times there is no way to assure safety in this city. And it's alarming for this correspondent to hear the same line from both the Taliban and one of the city's top cops: Insurgents can hit the city anytime, anywhere.

That's not to say the Kabul Police force isn't trying. They are now talking about a double ring of security around the city and they've gotten better at enforcing it. Many cities around the world with many more resources, are having their own battle with terrorists and so in that context, the security forces here aren't doing a bad job.

Securing this capital is a crucial test not only for the city's police force, but for the whole country. They need to know they can stand on their own and sort out their own security without thousands of foreign troops turning their capital into a fortress.

Less than three years ago, foreigners could walk the streets of Kabul in relative safety and have the luxury and freedom to hail their own cabs and try out the local food. Some foreigners of course still do that, but the majority live in armed camps throughout the city, fearing both random attacks and targeted kidnappings.

I saw first hand the pictures from inside a recent attack on the Justice Ministry here. It was gruesome, stomach-churning stuff. The images of dead employees with bullets to the head and chest were bad enough, but the placid expressions of the dead Taliban fighters, some of whom had major body parts blow off, were chilling.

The Taliban claims it controls several of the main routes just outside the city and not many Afghans are willing to test that claim. Roadside bombs have tripled so far this year and then there are the "Taliban checkpoints" that are harrowing for Afghans, let alone foreigners.

The fact is, even if Kabul becomes more secure in the coming months it may remain virtually cut off from the rest of the country for some time. And then there's still the issue of how to secure the city itself with a police force of grossly underpaid officers who claim they are on the take just to survive?

When I stopped at police headquarters at District #2, the commander there showed equal amounts of hubris and humility. Of course he said, he and his officers are heroes. But how else would you describe men who willingly walk the city knowing they could be target practice for the Taliban? And all for less than $200 a month.

I would like to hear what you think of the mission in Afghanistan. Let me know.

Posted by: ,
Filed under: Afghanistan • Taliban


Share this on:
Nathan   March 12th, 2009 1441 GMT

I am currently in Kabul. The security situation is not so dire as the headline reads. "Kabul's enemy at the gates" brings to mind Great Game siege scenes. While the security situation remains tenuous, hyperbole will only lead to panic rather than a cool-headed assessment of the situation.

If you want to look at a place where people almost dare not go, look at Kandahar (or even a border village). Far worse than Kabul, which sees less violence than Belfast during the Troubles, Kandahar represents a real problem. Meanwhile, Kabul moves on.

It's not paradise but your expectations that it should be are misguided. So is the view that a horde of Islamists on horseback will soon be racing through the streets. Is this perhaps a case of a reporter taking everything her hired security guard says at face value?

The real problems are that 1) with insufficient forces, we cannot hold what we clear; and 2) we alienate the people we are supposed to be supporting. Thankfully, we recognize these problems and are actually trying to correct them.

Matt Berg   March 12th, 2009 1638 GMT

The taliban are comparable with the vietcong. They may be some of the smartest enemy ever faced in combat. I am on the forefront of the firefights and I know how they play the game. Geniuses.

They play us like a piano.

Debby   March 12th, 2009 1737 GMT

Nathan: Thanks for the level-headed comments. My loved one is in Kabul and it seems those there have similar feeling as you do. I agree with your comment about the “panic” elements to the headline. It is unwarranted to overstate the situation in the headline just to get the readers attention. It is an injustice to the reader.

mike hawk   March 13th, 2009 004 GMT

Who knows what since there is a sort of media blackout in afghanistan.

Though, I think kabul would be secure but then the soviet occupation when Pakistan was a "safe base" of the afghan resistance [with billions of saudi and american $$$ flowing] was able to control kandahar, mazar-e-sharif and kabul.

Unlike iraq, the battle is not the cities but the countryside which probably holds more population than the cities themselves. Afghanistan could be beautiful striking place but it is weird as the british found out....

Henry   March 13th, 2009 909 GMT

Matt, I doubt the Talibanis are that "smart", religious fanatics are seldom known for their brains nor reasoning power.

However their brainless will to sacrifice themselves makes them a dangerous opponent as well as their absolute ruthlessness. As well as their immense experience in guerrilla warfare. However do not mix smartness with experience nor slyness.

It is only one way to fight this style of enemy and that is to take of the gloves and fight back with the same ruthlessness and lack of respect for life. Dialogue is wasted upon these people, they only understand the ways they live by, i.e. the way of the sword..

That said, with non Talibani Afghanis the rule of engagement should be far different, and we should as now focus on rebuild, and cooperate and give the other Afghanis a better future so fewer people are lured into the ranks of the Taliban.

The West has to either be willing to fight more ruthlessly and with far more resources or pull out of there as the middle way leads nowhere.

Erik H   March 14th, 2009 1308 GMT

Henry, you sound just like a British person speaking of the American traitors fighting British troops during the Revolutionary War.
You probably have no idea what I'm talking about so I'll keep it short.

Why is every new enemy we fight "evil"?
Why is every war we fight a war that "must" be won?
I recall we lost Vietnam and we did just fine despite all the FEARING from a certain group here in the U.S about communists taking over the world.

I fought in Afghanistan with 10th Mtn Div (1-87 Inf) and it was joke back in 2001-2002 just as it is today.
War On Terror my ass.
War on common sense and you have fallen for it as millions of Americans blinded by some warped ideology of what patriotism is supposed to be?

Perhaps someday you will learn?

The Captain’s Journal » The Coming Battle for Afghanistan   March 16th, 2009 339 GMT

[...] Newton, CNN: Kabul is clogged with traffic and people and at the best of times there is no way to assure safety [...]

Leave Your Comment


 

Comments are moderated by CNN, in accordance with the CNN Comment Policy, and may not appear on this blog until they have been reviewed and deemed appropriate for posting. Also, due to the volume of comments we receive, not all comments will be posted.


subscribe RSS Icon
About this blog

Paula Newton and Andrew CareyNews and observations on the threats to international security and the challenges posed by terrorism to societies around the world. By CNN's International Security Correspondent, Paula Newton, and International Security Producer, Andrew Carey. From breaking news to background stories, from serious analysis to casual asides, if we think it's interesting we'll post it here.

Categories
Powered by WordPress.com VIP